I thought this product was really awesome, but different than what I expected. It's almost the consistency of a gel eyeliner- really creamy but thick. I can actually use this as an eyeliner. The issue with it for me was layering- too much looks intense but it becomes uncomfortable to wear- very cakey and hard. Before it dried, I couldn't use it with any other products or it would get clumpy and rub off. For these reasons, I was unable to use it as a base for any other shadows, which was disappointing, especially the white shade.
My lighting must have been really, really different...I dont know what that's about!!