I got these eyeshadows in Trench and Antique Rose. I was in between Mulberry and Rosewood for what seemed like twenty minutes, but in the end I decided against Mulberry, it was just too dark for me to justify the splurge. It's a lot of product in these, so I wanted to get something I know I'd use. I was all set on Rosewood until I saw Antique Rose, which I think suits me well. I could really do without Trench, it's not that it's bad but I prefer a frostier or more pinkish tone for a highlighter. It's so close to my own skin tone, I don't see the point.
The texture is just amazing- so buttery soft and silky. They both have a satiny finish. I don't know why my swatch of Antique Rose turned out so brown, it really is more mauve on my eye with a primer.
Antique Rose- with primer
The fingerprint magnet packaging kinda bothers me though!