The formula is really, really dry and thick. My tube isn't old and I am sure it's supposed to be this way so it can live up to its claims of being water, sweat, and tear- proof. I haven't used waterproof mascara in a really long time though!
Here are my results:
The best thing about it is that I can honestly say it absolutely lives up to its claims. Even after hours of strenuous outdoor activity, my mascara was still intact, I was really shocked!
Here is a photo I snapped afterwards, also because I've never really gotten Meteorites to show up in a photo either: